Top Mistakes To Avoid When Overseeding Your Lawn

Rated 4.9 Across 200+ Reviews



Overseeding is a vital lawn care proactive that helps repair and replenish lawns that have become damaged from foot traffic, harsh weather, disease, and more. However, overseeding is not without its challenges, and avoiding common mistakes can make the difference between a thriving lawn and one that struggles to take root. To help our readers see long-lasting results, we have compiled this list of common overseeding mistakes and how to avoid them for a lush, healthy, and happy lawn! 

Skipping Soil Preparation

Many homeowners overlook soil preparation because it can seem like an unnecessary extra step. The assumption is that if the lawn is already established, the soil beneath must be adequate for new seeds as well. Soil preparation requires extra time and effort, leading some to skip it in favor of quicker results.

Failing to prepare the soil can result in poor seed-to-soil contact, which is critical for germination. Compacted soil, in particular, can prevent roots from establishing themselves, leading to weak, sparse grass growth. Unprepared soil may have nutrient imbalances or improper pH levels that hinder seed germination and growth.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Aerate The Lawn: Use a core aerator to relieve soil compaction and create space for seeds.
  • Test Soil pH: Ensure pH is in the optimal range (usually 6.0-7.0) for grass growth.
  • Loosen Topsoil: Lightly rake the surface to improve seed-to-soil contact.

Careless Seed Selection

Choosing grass seed may seem straightforward, but many homeowners make the mistake of picking the wrong type of seed because they don’t consider the specific conditions of their lawn, such as climate, soil type, and sunlight exposure. There’s also a tendency to grab whatever seed is on sale or readily available, assuming all grass seed is the same.

Selecting the wrong seed can result in poor germination rates, a mismatched lawn appearance, or a turf that struggles to thrive in your specific climate. For example, using a cool-season grass in a warm climate can lead to browning and sparse coverage during hot months.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Research Grass Types: Choose seed suited to your climate (cool-season vs. warm-season) and lawn conditions (sun, shade).
  • Match Existing Grass: Select seed that complements the current grass species for uniformity.
  • Consult Local Experts: Seek advice from local garden centers or extension services.

Overseeding At The Wrong Time Of Year

Timing errors often stem from a lack of understanding about the growth cycles of different grass types. Some homeowners may overseed during periods that are convenient for their schedules rather than considering the optimal growing conditions for the grass seed.

Overseeding at the wrong time of year can lead to poor seed germination, stunted growth, and a failure to establish strong roots. Overseeding a cool-season lawn in mid-summer can cause the new grass to wither under the heat, while overseeding a warm-season lawn in late fall might not give the grass enough time to establish before dormancy.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Cool-Season Grasses: Overseed in early fall for best results.
  • Warm-Season Grasses: Overseed in late spring or early summer.
  • Monitor Local Conditions: Adjust timing based on your specific climate and weather patterns.

Not Mowing Low Enough Before Overseeding

Some homeowners may not realize the importance of mowing low before overseeding or may be concerned about stressing the existing lawn by cutting it too short. There’s also a tendency to leave the grass longer to provide shade for the new seeds, thinking it will protect them.

If the existing grass is too tall, the new seed may struggle to reach the soil and establish roots. This can result in uneven germination, with some areas thriving while others remain bare. Tall grass can also block sunlight and airflow, both of which are necessary for seedling development.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Mow An Inch Lower Than Normal: Cut grass to 1.5 inches for cool-season, and 2 inches for warm-season grasses.
  • Remove Clippings: Rake up and dispose of grass clippings to avoid smothering new seeds.
  • Mow Just Before Seeding: Time your mowing to immediately precede overseeding.

Improper Irrigation

Watering errors are often due to misunderstanding the delicate balance required for seed germination. Some people water too little, believing the seeds will survive on minimal moisture, while others may overwater in an attempt to ensure the seeds don’t dry out.

Underwatering can cause the seeds to dry out and die before they have a chance to germinate. Overwatering, on the other hand, can wash away seeds, cause soil erosion, or create an overly saturated environment that leads to fungal growth or rot.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Water Lightly & Frequently: Keep soil moist, not soggy, by watering 2-3 times daily.
  • Adjust Based On Conditions: Tailor watering frequency to weather and soil type.
  • Gradually Reduce Frequency: Once seeds germinate, decrease frequency and increase watering depth.

Applying Too Much Or Too Little Seed

It’s easy to misjudge the amount of seed needed, especially for those new to overseeding. Some may believe that more seed will result in a thicker lawn, while others might spread too little in an effort to save money or avoid overplanting.

Using too much seed can lead to overcrowding, where seedlings compete for resources like sunlight, water, and nutrients, resulting in weak and spindly grass. On the other hand, using too little seed can lead to sparse coverage, leaving the lawn susceptible to weed invasion and uneven growth.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Follow Seeding Guidelines: Use 3-4 pounds of seed per 1,000 square feet for most cool-season grasses.
  • Use A Spreader: Ensure even seed distribution with a broadcast spreader.
  • Err On The Side Of Less: Slightly under-seed rather than over-seed to prevent overcrowding.

Ignoring Post-Seeding Fertilization

Some homeowners skip fertilization after overseeding, either because they believe their soil is already nutrient-rich or because they’ve applied fertilizer earlier in the season and think it’s sufficient. There’s also the fear that too much fertilization might burn the new seedlings.

Without proper fertilization, new grass may not receive the essential nutrients needed for robust growth. This can lead to slow establishment, weak roots, and an inability to compete with existing grass and weeds. Conversely, applying a high-nitrogen fertilizer immediately after seeding can burn the delicate seedlings.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Choose A Starter Fertilizer: Opt for one with higher phosphorus content (10-20-10).
  • Fertilize Immediately Before/After: Time application to coincide with overseeding.
  • Avoid high-nitrogen fertilizers: Prevent burning seedlings by using products specifically for new grass.

Leaving New Seeds Unprotected

The final common mistake is underestimating the vulnerability of a newly seeded lawn. Homeowners may resume regular activities like mowing, walking on the lawn, or letting pets and children play on it too soon after overseeding, thinking that once the seeds are down, the hard work is over.

Newly seeded lawns are highly susceptible to damage from foot traffic, mowing, and even heavy rainfall. Disturbing the soil before the seeds have a chance to establish can displace them, leading to uneven growth or bare patches. Mowing too soon can damage the delicate seedlings before they are strong enough to recover.

Avoid The Mistake!

  • Limit Foot Traffic: Keep people and pets off the lawn for 2-3 weeks post-seeding.
  • Delay Mowing: Wait until new grass reaches 3 inches before the first mow, and cut on the highest setting.
  • Protect Against Heavy Rain: Use straw or seed blankets to shield seeds from being washed away.

Avoid All Overseeding Mistakes With Heartland’s Help!

Here at Heartland Turf & Landscape, we understand the importance of paying attention to the smallest details, especially when it comes to the delicate work of properly overseeing your Kansas City lawn! We have seen many homeowners struggle to achieve the lush and healthy growth they want for their grass, and it is often just one or two simple mistakes that prevent our clients from achieving landscaping greatness! 

To avoid the mistakes mentioned in this post, as well as any other easy-to-make mishaps, reach out to a local lawn care professional like us for seasonal overseeding services!